There is very little out there to research this story further. If you can, try to track down The Market Book by Thomas F. De Voe. (1862, Burt Franklin, New York, pages 462-464) I was able to locate a copy in the stacks of the University at Albany library.
spin of the land and our problem will be solved.
We are used to living in an age where television, newspapers, radio, and computers spread information quickly. And, as much as we hate to admit it, our population is much better educated than at any other time during history.
So, let us set our timepieces back to an age before all of this technology. We’ll head back to the mid-1820’s when people gathered in central community squares to hear the latest news and gossip. In particular, we will take a look at one specific community forum, the one that was located at the junction of Centre, Grand, and Baxter Streets in the heart of Manhattan, New York City, New York State, United States of America, North America, Planet Earth… You get the idea.
The Centre Market was a place where the local butchers and tradesmen gathered to discuss the latest news. A rumor had started to spread through this and several other neighborhoods that the tip of Manhattan Island was sinking into the ocean. For proof, all one had to do was take a look down at the Battery and see how that end of the island dipped down into the water. Clearly, the weight of all of the buildings that had been constructed there was the culprit.
In these days before most people knew anything about geology and the solid nature of the Manhattan bedrock, concern started to take hold. People talked about the problem for several months, but no one had a clue as to how they could solve it.
What to do? What to do?
Enter the main character in this bizarre story, a man that went under the pseudonym of Lozier. Lozier, a retired ship’s carpenter, was fairly well educated for his time. When word reached him about the island’s dilemma, he decided that action needed to be taken. And Lozier decided that he was just the man to take it.
The best proposal that anyone had at the time was to saw off the end of Manhattan at Kingsbridge, which is located at the northern end of the island. The land would then be rowed out to sea, spun around, and then towed back in. The heavy end would then be located closer to the mainland and new zoning laws would be passed to prevent further development on the lighter end of the island.
Amazingly, the major concern with this solution was not that it was considered it impossible, but that Long Island stood in the way. People suggested that Long Island would likewise need to be detached and towed out to sea. With Long Island anchored securely out of the way, there would be ample room to make the grand turn needed to save Manhattan. Then, once Manhattan was back in place, Long Island would be towed back to its original location.
Are you buying all this? As unrealistic as this scheme seems to us today, Lozier was about to set one of the most bizarre hoaxes in history into motion.
Lozier got to work getting people to buy into the idea. Day after day he would strike up conversations with complete strangers about the problem. Word started to spread and many people started to offer their services. Lozier signed up carpenters to build the many barracks required to house the hundreds of workmen. He then enlisted the support of men to build the giant saws and the twenty-four sweeps needed to “sweep” the island around once it was detached.
Yet the most important job was that of the “pitmen”. Lozier figured that if you were going to saw an island off, then someone would have to be located on the end of the saw that was beneath the water’s surface. As a result, Lozier offered triple the compensation to those men that were qualified to be pitmen.
And what were the qualifications to be a pitman? Very
You had to hold your breath for a long time. Long lines formed
this great- paying job. Men would hold their breath until they
ready to explode while Lozier timed them. The men with the
times were given the honor of being a pitman.
I bet you can see where this story is headed…
The day for the project finally arrived and all of the men met at the specified locations. That is, all of the men except Lozier. He was nowhere to be found.
Almost immediately, the workers began to suspect that they had become a victim of an elaborate hoax. Yet, with typical male pride, hardly anyone would admit to having been tricked. Instead, they began to ridicule the few men that would admit to falling for the hoax.
And what happened to Lozier? He simply went into hiding, for obvious reasons. After several weeks, he reemerged in disguise. He once again assumed his identity, but his real name has been lost to history.
So is this story really true? I have no clue. Thomas F. De Voe, who just happened to have been appointed the Superintendent of Markets for New York City in December of 1871, records the earliest existing documentation of the hoax in The Market Book. He claims that it was his Uncle John De Voe who actually first told Lozier of the problem with the island. True or false, it still makes for a great story.
Useless? Useful? I’ll leave that for you to decide.
If you liked this story, please check out