A November 4, 1970 review of the album titled “Writer: Carole King” just tore into her singing ability.
“It is notable that the title of this album is not ‘Singer: Carole King.’ Carole King may be an excellent writer, but as a singer, she is barely competent. Her vocal range is very limited, she can’t sing any high notes, and at times her voice sounds flat and bored.”
The article continues, “The tunes and the instrumentation help make up for the fact that Carole King can barely sing, making this album enjoyable if somewhat vacuous.”
It concludes that the songs may appear on other artists’ albums in the future, “But this is probably the first and only album Carole King will ever make.”
You probably know the story about her next album titled Tapestry: It was the number 1 best selling album for fifteen consecutive weeks, had the second longest run of any album on the Billboard 200 chart after Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon, and to date has sold over 25 million copies.