This story begins on August 17, 1900, when Albert and Macy Johnston welcomed their newborn son Albert Chandler Johnston on August 17, 1900. He would be the first of their three children, all of whom were boys.
Educated in the Chicago public schools, young Albert excelled in his studies. So, after graduation, he went on to earn his Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Chicago. After that, he began his studies to become a doctor at Chicago’s Rush Medical College.
It was in September 1923 that his life would forever be changed. That’s when 19-year-old Boston resident Thyra Agatha Baumann opted to take a 2-week vacation in Chicago. Her family knew a couple there who had a young daughter who was around the same age, and she arranged for Thyra and Albert to meet.
It was love at first sight. The two spent a lot of time together, and on the day before Thyra was scheduled to return home to Boston, Albert took her to the University to show her around, made a visit to his fraternity Kappa Alpha Psi, and then suggested that she stay in Chicago and marry him.
When Thyra informed her parents that she was engaged, they were not happy. But after he came to Boston to meet them, they offered up their approval. Thyra and Albert were married on Christmas Day, December 25, 1924.
Initially, the two lived together, but after their son Albert Chandler Johnston, Jr. was born one year later, on December 19, the couple was forced to live apart. Thyra returned to Boston with their newborn, while Albert Sr. remained in Chicago to continue his medical studies. Financial hardship made this separation necessary. Albert Sr.’s father, Albert V. Johnston, a real estate agent in Chicago, had passed away around the time Albert and Thyra first met, leaving him without family support. The high cost of medical school, along with expenses for housing and supporting a new family, pushed him to work nearly all his spare hours. He took on a range of jobs, including working as a railroad waiter and porter, and pulling long night shifts at the post office.
Needless to say, he made it through and now just had to complete one final step before Rush would issue him an M.D. degree: he was required to get some real-world experience by interning at a first-rate hospital. But Albert was having a tough time finding a placement. The only hospitals that were willing to accept him did not meet the college’s high standards.
His luck changed when he received a welcoming telegram from Main General Hospital (today known as Maine Medical Center) in Portland, Maine. And with that, the Johnstons were off to Portland.
Upon completion of his internship, the head of the board of registration at the hospital told Albert that a friend of his, Dr. H. H. Bryant, had recently passed on and that he should look into taking over his general practice.
Albert traveled to the small town of Gorham, New Hampshire, population 2,500, and at the base of Mt. Washington, and liked what he saw. Dr. Bryant’s widow offered to sell all of her husband’s equipment and his goodwill for $1,000 (roughly $20,000 today). And he agreed to make the purchase. Albert obtained a $2,000 loan from the Gorham bank, rented a 5-room furnished apartment, and it wasn’t long before the rest of his family joined him.
Of course, being a country doctor was very demanding. At a time when doctors still made house calls, he could be called at just about any hour of the day to deal with a birth or an emergency. But he loved the job and the people of Gorham.
It wasn’t long before Dr. Johnston was making very good money, and with an ever-growing family – the Johnstons would eventually have three sons and a daughter – they decided that they needed a larger home. And large it was. They purchased a 3-story, 17-room house, complete with a large reception hall, that sat high up on a hill that overlooked the town.
The Johnstons were immediately accepted into the Gorham community. Dr. Johnston was elected to the school board and was a member of both the Masonic Lodge and the Rotary Club. Mrs. Johnston was active in civic work, was twice asked to assume the presidency of the Gorham Women’s Club, and served as president of the White Mountain Junior League of the Congressional Church.
They had been living in that large home for three years when Dr. Johnston received an offer to become a roentgenologist at a nearby hospital. The only catch was that he would need to go back to college to obtain the necessary training.
And with that, the Johnstons picked up and moved to Boston for a year. They rented an apartment in Brookline, enrolled the children in public school, and Dr. Johnston began a post-graduate course in roentgenology at Harvard.
Upon completion of his studies, Dr. Johnston took a radiology position at the hospital in Keene, New Hampshire, which is located roughly 100 miles (~160 km) southwest of Gorham. With a population roughly five times that of Gorham, they were concerned about fitting in, but the community quickly accepted them.
Around the same time, their son Albert Jr. was accepted to the Mount Hermon boys’ preparatory school in Gill, Massachusetts, which is about a 40-minute drive from Keene. This may seem like a very minor detail, but as you will soon see, it plays a pivotal part in the story.
Needless to say, the Johnstons loved their new life in Keene. They purchased another large home at the corner of Washington and Beaver Streets. (127 Washington St, Keene, NH 03431)
When the 1940s rolled around, it was becoming increasingly clear that the United States would be somehow pulled into World War II. And, of course, wars need doctors. The US Navy approached Dr. Johnston twice with offers of a commission, but he initially declined. But he knew that he would eventually get the call, and concluded that if he applied early, he would get a better placement.
That’s exactly what he did. He travelled to Boston for his physical. His WWII draft registration card described his physical features: 41 years old, 5 feet, 4-1/2 inches (~164 cm), 142 pounds (~64.5 kg), brown hair, brown eyes, white race, dark complexion. Albert was a bit too short and overweight for active combat, but there was a shortage of radiologists, so they decided to accept him. He was told that he would be appointed as a Lieutenant Commander in the Navy.

Albert was overjoyed and told everyone he knew about it. That was until a young man in a uniform came to his door. He said, “Dr. Johnston, I am sent here by the Bureau of Naval Intelligence to ask you a few questions.” He then glanced down at a sheet of paper and asked, “You graduated from the University of Chicago in 1924?” He asked a bit more and then politely excused himself, thanking the doctor for his time.
A few days later, a letter arrived in the mail from the Navy’s Bureau of Investigation. Dated August 1941, it was brief and stated that they were unable to approve his application because of his “Inability to meet naval physical requirements.”
Around the same time his father received the rejection, Albert Jr. got an unexpected surprise. A major ski meet was approaching, and the coach had selected six boys from Mount Hermon to represent the school. Although Albert Jr. wasn’t initially chosen, his close friend Charlie Duncan was. Believing Albert was the stronger skier, Charlie offered to give up his spot so Albert could compete instead. In the end, the coach decided to expand the team to seven, allowing both boys to attend the meet.

Needless to say, sixteen-year-old Albert was elated by the news and decided to hitchhike home for the weekend to tell his parents what had happened. But as soon as he stepped into the house, he could sense something was wrong—his father was clearly troubled. Albert Jr. didn’t yet know about the military’s decision, but he was about to find out.
Clearly, this wasn’t a good time to talk to his father, so he went upstairs to take a bath in the bathroom adjoining his parents’ bedroom. His plan was to go out with some girls that evening. As he began to fill the tub with water, he told his parents of what had happened: how Charlie Duncan had offered to give up his seat, how good of both a student and athlete was, and how much everyone liked Charlie, even though he was black.
It was at that moment that his dad turned to his wife, Thyra, and said, “I’m going to tell that boy.”
She begged him not to do so, but he poured himself a stiff drink, his third of the evening, and returned to the bathroom door. He told his son to turn off the water and said, “Do you know something, boy?”
His son answered, “No, what?”
Dad’s reply was, “Well, you’re colored.”
It was true. Dr. and Mrs. Johnston were African American, but their skin was light enough that the two of them could pass for being white. And that was their white lie: they were lying that they were white.
The couple went on to explain everything to their son but cautioned him to keep it a secret—even from his younger siblings. If word got out, Dr. Johnson risked not only his career but also the respect of their friends and neighbors.

So now I should back up to the very beginning of the story and fill in the details that I purposely skipped to keep you in suspense for a bit:
Growing up in Chicago, Dr. Johnston was one of just two Black students in his high school graduating class. He was relatively light-skinned, but his father—whom I’ll refer to as Papa Johnston for clarity—was even lighter. This allowed Papa Johnston to pass as white, which opened the door to a successful career in real estate. His family had always lived in the North and had never been enslaved. The same, however, could not be said of Mama Macy Johnston. She was from the South, and both of her parents had been enslaved in Mississippi.
As mentioned earlier, Dr. Johnston studied at Rush Medical College, where he was one of only two Black students in his class—the maximum the school admitted each year. At the time, nearly every Rush student completed their internship at nearby Presbyterian Hospital. But for Albert and the other Black student, that requirement was quietly set aside; administrators feared the hospital’s patients would object to being treated by a Black physician.
As for why Dr. Johnston had such a difficult time finding a hospital to intern, it was very simple. Of the four Black hospitals in the US that were open to black interns, none met the high standards that Rush accepted. He applied to other hospitals, but once they learned of his race, they turned him down. And that’s how he ended up at Maine General. His wife Thyra suggested that he simply not state his race, unless asked. And since they never asked, he never told them. And that’s how the two began living as white people.
Now let’s take a deeper look at Thyra’s background: One of her grandfathers, who was white, had moved from Germany to New Orleans. There, he found great success, becoming Shipping Commissioner of the Port of New Orleans. It was also there that he married Thyra’s grandmother, who was Black.
In the early 1900s, there was segregation everywhere, except in federal offices. This worked out well for Thyra’s father, who worked as a clerk in the Post Office there. But after Woodrow Wilson was elected President in 1912, her dad feared even greater segregation in New Orleans and asked to be transferred to a post office in Boston. Thyra was nine years old when the family moved north.
While I couldn’t confirm this, one source said that Thyra was only 1/8 black, so her skin was very light. In addition, she had light brown hair and blue eyes, so it was easy for her to pass as a white woman. And that’s exactly what she did. When she applied for jobs, she purposely left the question of race blank on job applications.
When it came time for dating, Thyra’s dad was very concerned about his daughter dating a darker-skinned man. Passing as a white person entitled them to many privileges that they had been denied back in New Orleans, and he didn’t want her to be subjected to all of that discrimination.
Which is why they were so concerned when Thyra took that two-week trip out to Chicago, met Albert Johnston, and they decided to get married. Her parents would not allow the marriage to go forward without them first meeting Albert in person, to make certain that he wasn’t dark skinned.
Of course, when Albert took over the late Dr. Bryant’s practice in Gorham, they continued to keep their racial secret. This was at a time when Gorham had a KKK chapter, and neither Blacks, Jews, nor Catholics were accepted. But no one ever asked them, and no one ever figured it out.
Which brings us back to that rejection from the Navy. When Dr. Johnston applied to the Navy, he was fully aware that they thoroughly investigated the background of all commissions, but he was willing to take that risk.
It’s unknown how the Navy discovered that Albert was Black, but it probably wasn’t very difficult. Not only did his World War I draft registration card list his race as Negro, but so did his birth certificate. Add to the evidence that he was a member of Kappa Alpha Psi, an African American fraternity, while in medical school.
Which meant that when that young man from the Bureau of Naval Intelligence showed up at his door to ask him some questions, they already knew. That’s because he said, “We understand that, even though you are registered as white, you have colored blood in your veins.”
To which Dr. Johnston replied, “Who knows what blood any of has in his veins.”
Several days later, that letter of rejection arrived, and we’ve arrived back at the moment when Albert and Thyra told their son that he was Black.
Albert Jr. had spent the first sixteen years of his life thinking he was white. Now he would have to adapt to being a light-skinned black man. He did not deal with it well.
After graduating from Mt. Hermon, he went to study at Dartmouth, but he wasn’t able to adapt. When he was nearly on the verge of suicide, his father came and took him out of college.
Then he joined the Navy, where he passed as white, but ended up in a psychiatric hospital there. They discharged him as a “psycho neurotic unclassified.”
The young man was clearly a lost soul. Then, one spring day, a friend from Gorham named Walt called to say that he was hitchhiking to Syracuse, NY, and asked if Albert would like to come along. He agreed, and soon the two were hitchhiking across the entire continent together.
Their journey took them to Niagara Falls, then to Cleveland to stay with Dr. Johnston’s brother, then to Chicago to see even more family, and finally to Los Angeles to visit a cousin. By spending time with his relatives, Albert learned what it was like to live among other African Americans. After completing this spiritual journey, he decided to return home and enrolled as a music major at the University of New Hampshire.
He didn’t know it at the time, but this decision would forever change the lives of the Johnston family. Their secret would soon be known by the entire nation.
While at the University of New Hampshire, Albert Jr. befriended other black students, something he hadn’t had the opportunity to do in either Gorham or Keene.
When Albert and his friend Bill Ballard learned that Academy Award-winning director Louis de Rochemont was living in nearby Newington, they decided to drive over to talk to him. It’s unclear how they got this meeting, but one newspaper article stated that Albert Jr. had met de Rochemont after he gave a lecture on campus.
At the time, de Rochemont was at the peak of his fame. His “The March of Time” newsreels had been seen by millions of people, but once the war ended, he decided to focus on bigger projects. He specialized in turning real stories, filmed on actual locations, that he could turn into hit movies.
When they arrived at this home, the two explained to de Rochemont that they were unhappy with the way black people were always portrayed on film. Audiences never got to see black doctors, black lawyers, and all of the black professionals. They wished to change that and suggested that de Rochemont make a film about someone like George Washington Carver or Booker T. Washington.
So, de Rochemont listened intently to what the boys had to say. While De Rochemont could clearly see the dark color of Bill Ballard’s skin, he began to wonder why the light-skinned Albert Johnston would be so concerned. That’s when Albert told him that he had only learned that he was Black two years prior.
Albert then told the whole story to de Rochemont, and he instantly knew that would be the subject of his next movie. But he wouldn’t tell the story without the permission of all those involved, namely Dr. and Mrs. Johnston.
So, Albert Jr. hitchhiked home and explained to his parents how de Rochemont wanted to tell their story on film. The couple stayed up all night debating the pros and cons of revealing their secret. Dr. Johnston was concerned that he would lose his position at the hospital and that the family would no longer be accepted as members of the community. Thyra assured him that the people of Keene knew him well and that it wouldn’t happen. She expressed that she was tired of hiding the truth.
In the end, the couple agreed to have their story told. They were paid $10,000 (~$145,000 today), all of which was given to their children.
Of course, making movies is costly, so de Rochemont needed to test the waters to see how receptive the public would be to the story about a black family passing as white. He had an agreement with Reader’s Digest that allowed him to provide them with story ideas, after which he retained the option to make it into a film.
Readers’ Digest agreed and asked William Lindsay White to pen the story. The result was the 92-page book “Lost Boundaries,” from which the magazine published a condensed version of in their December 1947 issue. The story became one of the most popular ever published in the magazine to that date, and soon production of the film began.
The movie, which was one of the first major films in the United States to deal with race relations, starred Mel Ferrer and Beatrice Pearson. Lost Boundaries opened on June 22, 1949, at both the Colonial and Olympia Theatres in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. After that, it opened at the Astor Theatre in New York City, and was then distributed nationwide after that. Well, mostly nationwide. It was banned in a couple of cities. Reviews were nearly universally positive, and de Rochemont was able to clear a profit on his investment.
I’m going to skip discussing the movie further right now. That’s because my wife Mary Jane and I watched it a few weeks ago, and we plan to discuss it in the next episode of this podcast. What I will say in advance of that is that there was something about the movie that was initially quite jarring, but when it was over, the two of us were still talking about it a week later. So, stay tuned for that.
Meanwhile, back in Keene, the community had finally come to learn of the Johnstons’ secret. Their response was kind of a mixed bag. The fact was that there had been rumors going around for years that they were black, but no one really cared. And, yes, there were those who were angered by the revelation.
About one month after the movie’s release, Dr. Johnston told those attending a New York Press Club’s luncheon that if he could do it all over again, he wouldn’t attempt to hide that he was a black man.
But things weren’t so rosy in his professional life. There were repeated attempts by the Board of Trustees at the Keene hospital to oust him from his radiologist position. They finally succeeded in doing so in June 1953. The hospital claimed that he was dismissed because he had neglected his duties, but the general consensus was that he was really let go because of the color of his skin.
It was a setback, but Dr. Johnston wasn’t unemployed. He was still on the staff of other regional hospitals, plus he set up a private practice on the first floor of his home. He would continue doing so until his retirement in 1967. The couple then moved to Hawaii, where he continued to work part-time as a radiologist.
Dr. Albert Chandler Johnston passed away on June 23, 1988. He was 87 years old and requested that his body be taken back to Keene, the town that he loved, for burial. His wife Thyra Baumann Johnston lived until November 22, 1995. She was 91 years old. Lastly, their son, Albert Jr., was 88 when he passed away in Hawaii in 2014. Useless? Useful? I’ll leave that for you to decide.
