(This story was originally written and recorded for Retrocast 45, released on October 20, 2026.)
On Saturday, February 8, 1969, my parents held a going-away party at their home in Brooklyn for my dad’s younger brother, Mel, who had been drafted to fight in Vietnam.
I was too young to understand what was at stake, but I’m certain the adults at that party understood the risks all too well. The war was not going well, and there was a very real possibility that my uncle might never come home.
As it turned out, Mel never had to serve. That evening, New York City was hit by a blockbuster snowstorm that brought the city to a standstill. Somehow, my uncle managed to make his way to the induction facility, as did one other man. Thanks to the storm, no other recruits showed up.
For whatever reason, the examining doctor decided that both men were unfit for military service. Over the years, I’ve heard different explanations. My uncle may have been rejected because he was flat-footed or too skinny, while the other fellow was supposedly too heavy. Whatever the reasons, both men were sent home, and neither had to serve in Vietnam.
That story about my uncle came to mind while I was researching the story I’m about to tell you. It concerns four brothers named Gabriel who lived with their parents in a two-story farmhouse near Ontarioville, Illinois, about 25 miles (40 km) northwest of Chicago.
All four brothers opposed fighting in a war on religious grounds. So, when the oldest brother, Albert, received notice that he was to report for induction on July 6, 1942, the family made a rather drastic decision. All four brothers would go into hiding.
It’s worth noting that the three younger brothers were all old enough to be subject to the draft, yet none of them had even registered for it.
Needless to say, this was illegal, and the federal government was determined to find them. After roughly two years, the case landed in the hands of FBI agent Edward W. Halloran.
Halloran was convinced that the brothers’ parents knew exactly where their sons were hiding. The problem was that whenever investigators visited the family home to ask questions, their mother would promptly faint, while their father, Charles, would expose a cancerous wound on his neck and claim that he was unable to speak.
It was quite a performance, and apparently, the parents were sticking to their roles.
Although the farmhouse wasn’t under round-the-clock surveillance, the FBI kept a close watch on the property. Despite their efforts, investigators never once saw any of the missing men enter or leave the house.
Eventually, the FBI informed Charles that a nationwide search for his sons was about to begin. Whether that was actually true is unclear, but the family soon realized that the situation had become far too serious to ignore.
On July 8, 1946, the four Gabriel brothers – Albert, 40; Frank, 29; Henry, 26; and Ernest, 23 – walked into their local FBI office and surrendered.
Their hiding place turned out to be right under the investigators’ noses. For all 47 months of their disappearance, the brothers had been living in a small room in their parents’ attic!
Knowing that the FBI was keeping an eye on the house, they took extraordinary precautions. They ventured outside only on dark, moonless nights, when they would run along a cow path to get some exercise.
Whenever investigators came to the house, the brothers quickly covered the attic’s one small window. Meanwhile, downstairs, their parents would spring into action, with their mother fainting and their father pretending to be too ill to speak.
After nearly four years of hiding, the brothers had finally given themselves up. Each was held on $5,000 bond, equivalent to nearly $86,000 today. Unfortunately for the family, that was money they simply didn’t have.
On July 19, 1946, just eleven days after surrendering, all four brothers pleaded guilty to violating the Selective Service Act. Each offered his own explanation for refusing to fight.
Albert said, “I heard too much of the horror of World War I.”
Frank explained, “I did not want to violate the 5th commandment.” [‘Thou shalt not kill.’]
Henry declared, “I would not bear arms even if America were invaded.”
And Ernest stated, “I do not believe in violence of any kind.”
Their religious convictions may have been sincere, but the judge presiding over their case was not impressed by their decision to evade the draft for nearly four years.
As he handed down their sentences, Judge Walter J. LaBuy remarked, “The thing that amazes me is to find four brothers all equally disloyal. Your actions were certainly cowardly in letting others fight for you. If you’d done this in Austria, from where your family came, you’d have been shot.”
The judge then sentenced each of the four brothers to three years in a federal penitentiary for violating the Selective Service Act.
And so, after spending nearly four years hiding in their parents’ attic to avoid military service, the Gabriel brothers were headed somewhere they certainly hadn’t planned on going: to federal prison.